Loading...
Negative Spillover Effects of Opt-out Defaults: Evidence from Organ Donation Policies
Güntürkün,Pascal Studte,Sinika Winkler,Daniel Clement,Michel Merz,Eva-Maria Tan,Jonathan Veld,Elisabeth Huis in 't Ferguson,Eamonn
Güntürkün,Pascal
Studte,Sinika
Winkler,Daniel
Clement,Michel
Merz,Eva-Maria
Tan,Jonathan
Veld,Elisabeth Huis in 't
Ferguson,Eamonn
Abstract
Many of today’s pressing societal challenges,such as the shortage of organs for transplantation, low vaccination rates, or the progression of climate change,requiresignificant changes in individual behavior. One promising intervention to encourage such behavioral change is the opt-out default, which presumes consent to a desirable behavior rather than relying on people to actively opt in. However, past research mainly studied how opt-out defaults affect the targeted behavior but largely omitted the possibility of negative spillover effects on related behaviors. Here, we study the possibility of such negative spillover effectson living organ donation (the related behavior) when countries switch to opt-out organ donation targeted at deceased donation. Analyzingepidemiological panel data from countries that switched to an opt-out default between 2000 and 2019,we show that switching to an opt-out default policy, on average, increased deceasedorgan donors by 2.79 per million population (pmp)––i.e., a relative uplift of +18% in the targeted behavior––but also decreased livingorgan donors by -3.56 pmp––i.e., a relative drop of -62% in a related behavior––resulting in an overall net-zero effect. Using a comparativecountry survey and experiment, we demonstrate that this reduced willingness for living altruistic (vs. familial) donations is attributable to people being less willing to become a living donor because they hold stronger beliefs that the organ supply is sufficientlymet under opt-out (vs. opt-in). Our research advances insights into the unintended consequences of default nudgesand offers initial suggestions on how to overcome negative spillover effects.
Description
EMM’s contribution has been funded by the European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program (Grant agreement No. [802227]). JT gratefully acknowledges the financial support from Nanyang Technological University under the Start-Up Grant, and the Ministry of Education Singapore under the AcRF Tier 1 Grant (RG126/20). EF gratefully acknowledges the financial support from NIHR Blood and Transplant Research Unit in Donor Health and Behaviour (NIHR203337). The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Date
2024-08-20
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Research Projects
Organizational Units
Journal Issue
Keywords
behavioral interventions, default nudges, public health policy, organ donation, spillover effects
Citation
Güntürkün, P, Studte, S, Winkler, D, Clement, M, Merz, E-M, Tan, J, Veld, E H I & Ferguson, E 2024, Negative Spillover Effects of Opt-out Defaults : Evidence from Organ Donation Policies. https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/c36v8
License
info:eu-repo/semantics/restrictedAccess